They Loved The Darkness…

Jeff Fuller July 29th, 2008

What do you think happens when a handful of evangelists set up a small box to preach the gospel to folks waiting in line for a Todd Bentley event? Before reading this account, I wanted to believe they would receive the Word with gladness and give the preaching a hearty “Amen!” Yet that is not what our friend Tony Miano and his group experienced:

 

Guest Post from Tony Miano.

“And this is the judgment: the light has come into the world, and people loved the darkness rather than the light because their works were evil. For everyone who does wicked things hates the light and does not come to the light, lest his works should be exposed. But whoever does what is true comes to the light, so that it may be clearly seen that his works have been carried out in God” (John 3:19-21)

There is so much about the post you are about to read that I wish I did not have to write. But the story is too important not to tell.

Thirteen fellow evangelists and I went to the Galen Center (USC). The purpose of our trip was to bring the Law and the Gospel to those waiting in line to enter the center, to hear the false prophet, Todd Bentley, and others.

When we arrived at the Galen Center, members of the team attempted to distribute gospel tracts to those standing in line. Based on the reports I received, half of the people in line refused to take the tracts. It should be noted that the tract made no mention of Todd Bentley or any other spiritual personality.

I am not ashamed to admit that before stepping onto the box, I felt as nervous as I have ever felt before preaching in the open air. I was so nervous that I asked for more prayer. Members of the team gathered around me, laid hands on me, loved me, and prayed.

I began my first open-air with the following words:

“Folks, many of you are here today because you believe the Holy Spirit will be in this place. I do not know you so I do not presume to question your sincerity. But are you sure what will take place here, today, will be brought about by the Holy Spirit? Or is it possible, even likely, that what will take place here today will be the work of other spirits?”

The crowd was very quick to respond…and they weren’t happy. They began to yell, chant, sing, and do everything they could to silence my preaching. As you can see in the above photo, they even turned their backs.

One-by-one, the hecklers left the line to engage me and the others on my team. Some were reasonable and kind. Others, like the “event staff” person in my face, in the above photo, ranted and raved like so many of the “unbelievers” we face every day on the streets.

At one point, before I finished preaching, two young girls (pictured above) left the line. They stood before me, dropped to their knees, raised their hands, and (I assume) were praying. I could not help to ask myself, “To whom are they praying? I was quoting Scripture–preaching the Law and the Gospel–and they were opposed to what I was doing. To whom would they pray to silence the preaching the gospel?”

It broke my heart.

After I finished preaching and then engaging several people who approached me in conversation, a young man named Christian walked up to me. He was there to attend the event.

At the risk of looking foolish and a bit out of control, I’m going to allow you to hear what Christian said, and my response. (I kept my digital recorder running almost continually during the event, since I did not know what we would face from event staff, security, local police, or the attendees.) This is what he said…

I was so brokenhearted by the people’s hatred for the Law and the Gospel (and yes, hatred for me) that I just lost it when I heard Christian’s words of encouragement. The emotion seemed to erupt from my heart.

Christian put his arms around me and prayed. I wept bitter tears on his shoulder.

It would be the only encouragement I would receive from those attending the event. It was more than enough. I told Christian that I believed he had been sent by the Lord.

It was time to move on. There was yet more work to do.

We made our way to the side of the building where there was yet another long line of people waiting for the doors of the Galen Center to open. First, we debriefed the last hour of evangelism, including my open-air.

We were in agreement that the quick and angry reaction to my first open-air was due to the fact that I began by attacking (in their mind) their idol–Todd Bentley. They responded the same way a Mormon would respond if I were to begin the conversation by pointing out the heresy of Joseph Smith. They responded the same way a Jehovah’s Witness would respond if I were to begin the conversation by pointing out the heresy of Charles Taze Russell. They responded the same way a Seventh Day Adventist would respond if I were to begin the conversation by pointing out the heresy of Ellen G. White.

By the time I reached the point of preaching of the Law and the Gospel, the crowd had worked itself up into an angry frenzy. Even with amplification, I had to yell to be heard above the crowd.

So, I told the team that this time I was simply going to preach the Law an the Gospel the same way I would in front of a DMV or courthouse. I would not make any mention of Todd Bentley or the Lakeland Revival. I wanted to see how long it would take for the people to express their hatred for the message and/or the messenger.

It wouldn’t take long…

I stepped onto the box. After introducing myself, I said that we have all sinned and have fallen short of the glory of God. And it began.

Like the line of people who heard my first open-air, the second group was quick to shout down my preaching. No argument could be made that I was attacking their idol. I simply preached the Law and the Gospel.

The hecklers for my second open-air were every bit as angry as the first group, and as angry as any group of “unbelievers” I have ever faced.

The angry man in the above photo rebuked me as if he were attempting to cast a demon from me. Imagine: a professing Christian thinking that a man preaching the Law and the Gospel is demon-possessed.

The moment of truth came when the elderly lady pictured above took me to task for speaking against Todd Bentley. I had not yet mentioned his name!

Now we were getting somewhere. The reason the people were so angry with the preaching of the Law and the Gospel and saw it as an attack against Bentley was that what they had heard and would hear from him was a different gospel.

If you are reading this and are a proponent of Todd Bentley and what is happening in Lakeland, Florida and other places around the world, you may try to levy the charge that I am anti-charismatic. While I am not charismatic in my theology, I am not anti-charismatic. And the above photo is evidence of this truth.

Meet Josh Elsom. He attended the Ambassadors’ Academy this weekend. He is charismatic in his theology. He is my brother in Christ. And, together, we brought the Law and the Gospel to the people standing in line.

I included the above photo because it is so very sad. “The Young Adult Prophet Squad.” And who is being glorified? Christ? The Holy Spirit? No. It’s the young adults who think they are prophets who are being glorified.

And the photo will help to make my final point.

During the one-to-one conversations we had yesterday afternoon, we repeatedly ran into a particular objection. The people were confused as to why we were preaching to them. “After all,” so they asserted, “we believe the same gospel. We preach repentance of sin and faith in Jesus Christ alone.”

The Mormons can make the same argument.

But, unlike the Mormons and other cults who believe in a Jesus that is not found in Scripture, these folks do believe in the Jesus of the Word of God. So, what’s the problem?

I think my experience outside the Galen Center provided the answer.

Yes, you will hear Todd Bentley and others like him talk about repentance. Yes, you will hear Todd Bentley and others like him talk about salvation by faith in Jesus Christ alone. But to what end? And therein lies the difference.

Todd Bentley and other false prophets and prophetesses like him preach repent and believe, not for salvation from sin and eternal life with Jesus Christ (even though they may say the words), but for the impartation of spirits and angels, and for manifestations of spiritual power in this temporal life. And, once again, therein lies the difference. The gospel of Todd Bentley is basically “Your Best Life Now” on spiritual steroids.

So, people go to Lakeland and the Galen Center, and other places around the world to “get some” of what Bentley and others are offering. They “repent and believe,” so to speak,” and then Jesus is quickly brushed aside for what they really came to receive–manifestations, spirits, angels, healing, predictions about a better life, and a spiritual shot in the arm.

Yes, there may have been genuine followers of Christ in the lines outside the Galen Center. (I made that point over and over again in my preaching that day.) While the Elect of God will never be so deceived as to become apostate (Matt. 24:24), they most certainly can be duped by false prophets for a season. My prayer for them is that they will repent and return to worshiping the Creator instead of worshiping the magical maneuvers of a fallen, sinful creatures.

For the lost who were there that day (and there were many), my prayer remains the same. I pray that they will repent and believe the one, true Gospel while they still have time.

For those of you who endured this very long post to the end, you can click here to listen to my second open-air outside of the Galen Center.

Episode 24 – Two Reformed Brothers

Jeff Fuller May 16th, 2008

Todd Bentley on Two Reformed Brothers Podcast

Join the broadcast this week for a look at Todd Bentley & the Florida Outpouring revival as we examine Bentley’s sermons on evangelism. In his sermon series, Evangelism to the Multitudes, “Todd calls the troops to attention for such a time as this!” And, “Your passion for the harvest will be blazing as you hear how the Lord of the Harvest is calling forth laborers now and how He wants to release a soul-winning anointing.” Listen live Sunday night at 8pm PST (11pm on the East Coast) or download the podcast following the show.

http://www.blogtalkradio.com/tworeformedbrothers

 

Fresh Fire or False Fire?

Jeff Fuller May 7th, 2008

I was recently told of a series of revival meetings taking place in Lakeland, Florida led by a guy named Todd Bentley. Coming from a pentecostal background, and believing in the continuation of gifts, I found it interesting to look over this man’s recent sermons to see what he is teaching. I’ve seen a lot of charismania in my lifetime so I wasn’t surprised by what I read in the transcripts of his weekly teachings.

Let me give you a little background. I was impacted years ago, and first introduced to this kind of intimacy, through the ministries of Benny Hinn and Kathryn Kuhlman. They opened the way for me to go beyond the power of God’s Spirit, the gifts or any kind of experience like the baptism of the Holy Spirit.As I look back, I can see that the person or presence of the Holy Spirit has become as real to me today as any man or woman would be anywhere I go. In fact, there are times when His presence is so real it’s as if a person is hovering over my shoulder. Or other times I’ll be walking along and I’ll sense His presence moving with me. I can feel it.

Now I want to ask you several questions. What goes through your mind when you think of the Holy Spirit? When you see somebody shake and fall down under the power, or when someone speaks in tongues, do you think, there’s the Holy Spirit!? Or when you see a gift of the Spirit, do you call it the Holy Spirit?

Actually, what you are seeing is the effect of the Spirit. But who is the Holy Spirit? I’m not talking about what He does—the Counselor or the Teacher. Who is He? Do you know what He feels? Do you know when He’s hurt? Do you know the emotions of the Holy Spirit? How much of the manifest presence of God’s Spirit do you know in your life?

For example, I know Him like I know my wife. There are times when my wife will just look at me and I’ll know what she is thinking. It’s like when you are in such close relationship with someone and you’re in their presence, you just know. Nothing is even said, you just know. So, how close are you?

Some of us think we have a relationship with the Holy Spirit; we can think of all the supporting scriptures and we invite the Holy Spirit to help us serve the Lord Jesus. We’re comfortable with the Father, we worship Jesus, and we pray to the Father in the name of Jesus. But there’s more.

The first paragraph of this man’s sermon tells me that this man is teaching a dangerous kind of intimacy, “They opened the way for me to go beyond the power of God’s Spirit….” Go BEYOND the power of God’s Spirit?!?! Wow, that’s a bold claim!

Sam Storms warns that “the pursuit of intimacy has often led people into unbiblical and dangerous waters and the possibility of drowning in a sea of subjectivity is very real.” Dr. Storms identifies 7 mistakes people make in their pursuit of intimacy with God, where men stray from the fact that we must pursue God within the parameters set forth in Scripture:

  1. It is possible, in our pursuit of intimacy with God, to allow our familiarity to degenerate into flippancy.
  2. It is possible, in our pursuit of intimacy with God, to fail to remember His transcendence by placing extreme emphasis on His immanence.
  3. It is possible, in our pursuit of intimacy with God, to lose sight of His holiness.
  4. It is possible, in our pursuit of intimacy with God, to overemphasize the subjective fruit to the exclusion of the objective foundation.
  5. It is possible, in our pursuit of intimacy with God, to fail to come to Him on His terms.
  6. It is possible, in our pursuit of intimacy with God, to lose sight of the distinction between Creator and creature.
  7. It is possible, in our pursuit of intimacy with God, to presume upon His grace.

It’s easy to see from Bentley’s own testimony that he has blurred the lines between God and man, speaking of the Spirit of God in a way that makes Him seem more of a buddy than a person of the Godhead. And he’s teaching outside the parameters of Scripture, though he briefly quotes singular passages throughout his sermons. I would call his focus that of radical application. What I mean is that his ministry is all about the application of Scriptures, leaving those who he is teaching without the context of what the Scriptures are actually saying to who the letters were actually written. Without that important foundation of context, there is no way for his congregation to know if the application he is teaching is credible.

For example, look at this reference from Ephesians Chapter 1 followed by Bentley’s application. Does he give enough of Ephesians to his congregation so that they can see that the text God has authored supports Bentley’s application?

Just look at what the Apostle Paul said in his prayer to the Ephesian church about our inheritance: “In Him also we have obtained an inheritance, being predestined according to the purpose of Him who works all things according to the counsel of His will” (Eph. 1:11). He goes on to describe three aspects in our inheritance: that we may know one, what is the hope of His calling; two, what are the riches of the glory of His inheritance in the saints; and three, what is the exceeding greatness of His power toward us who believe according to the working of His mighty power which He worked in Christ when He raised Him from the dead and seated Him at His right hand in the heavenly places (vv. 1:17–20, emphasis mine).

So, I’m not just focused on who I am in Christ, I’m focused on discovering who Christ is in me. In that discovery, I’m being drawn into a deep friendship with God in the secret place. That’s where I’m finding out more and more about the scope of my inheritance—for instance, reigning and resurrection power, and more. Conversely, if I was continually ignoring the Holy Spirit, even though I am born again and God’s word says I can enter the kingdom of God, I would not be in the right position to receive all of my inheritance.

Think about this. We can enter the kingdom of God, yes, but not everyone that enters the kingdom of God inherits the kingdom of God! The key to inheritance is intimacy and revelation and through this I know that, spiritually, I’ve been made a “king”. This is my spiritual status, to reign on this earth—and so I’m beginning to reign today! But, of course, without intimacy with God, I won’t have the reigning and resurrection power!

What’s more, what we gain as we advance and grow here, we take with us into eternity. Don’t miss this. The degree to which we faithfully act on the revelation God gives us, is the degree of responsibility that we will have in eternity. There are degrees; and this will affect our “brightness” in heaven. Every “star” differs in glory. We’re mistaken if we think that if we all ended up in heaven right now, we’d be equals; that somehow once we enter the pearly gates everything that I see, you see; and everything that becomes my experience, becomes your experience. Or that whatever we’ve done here doesn’t count.

I, for one, want to get to know God; I want to rule and reign in the universe and hang out with the angels. “God, can you create another planet with souls on it that need to be saved and send me there?” I want to talk about different things with Michael (archangel) and Gabriel (angel). “Come on Abraham! We’ve got to have a conversation about . . .” Heaven would be pretty boring if we just kind of showed up and said, “Here I am! Done!”

If you go to the text of Ephesians 1 you’ll find that Bentley’s application of the Scripture is skewed far from what Paul is communicating to the people of God. From reading several sermons, this is a trend. He’s clearly making this stuff up. If you don’t know the Bible, he isn’t giving it to you, so when you leave the meeting you are leaving with all this application that is just made up stuff with little to no biblical support. The snowball just gets bigger and bigger the more it rolls down the hill!

Recommended Resources

Dr. Timothy Beougher taught a James P. Boyce Society Lecture on the topic Theology of Revival. In it he gives a solid defense for revival along with a well balanced rule for judging genuine revival. A PDF handout outline is also freely available.

Engaging the Holy SpiritEngaging with the Holy Spirit: Real Questions, Practical Answers is a brief, reader-friendly book full of solid, reassuring answers by Graham Cole. One of the books endorsements reads, “Pneumatology has been sadly neglected in recent evangelical theology, and when it has been touched upon, it has trended toward either the speculative or the sensational. But here is a book on the Holy Spirit that is practical, relevant, balanced, and useful in the lives of God’s people everywhere. This book provides important grounding for a fuller theology of the Holy Spirit, and I commend it to all believers who are serious about the Christian life.”

Visit Our Sponsor